EDITORIAL METHOD

How HTL scores work.

An HTL score is an editorial assessment of a specific product or book. Each published score names the reviewer, explains the reasoning and identifies the sources used.

Provisional previews and completed reviews

HTL preview rating is an initial, AI-assisted editorial opinion based on the catalogue description and general category considerations. It considers the clarity of the intended use, practical trade-offs and the uncertainty surrounding the proposed benefits. It is not a full-book review or evidence of product testing, accuracy, durability, purity or medical effectiveness. Each preview includes its own explanation.

Preview ratings use a five-star scale: 1–2 means substantial reservations; 2.5–3 a mixed or specialised proposition; 3.5–4 a promising fit for a defined reader; and 4.5–5 a particularly clear practical or educational proposition. The number is subjective and provisional. A low score is not proof of a defect, and a high score is not a medical recommendation. Recalled products display a safety notice instead of a shopping rating.

Completed evaluations

A completed HTL evaluation names its reviewer, documents its sources and scores the three criteria below from 0 to 10. Their equally weighted average is divided by two for the five-star display. Completed evaluations take precedence over provisional previews. We do not import Amazon stars into either system.

Equipment

Supplements

Books

Research and direct experience

Research-based evaluations use documented specifications, relevant evidence and traceable sources. They do not imply that we used the product. “Hands-on evaluation” requires documented use. “Read & reviewed” requires that the reviewer read the book. A book score also considers how its claims and uncertainties are handled.

Supplement quality and health evidence

The supplement score concerns the named formulation, transparency, documented quality controls and practicality. A separate evidence summary explains the intended use, supporting research and limitations. A quality score does not establish medical effectiveness, safety for an individual or a reason to take a supplement.

Expected prices

An expected price is a broad editorial budget estimate for the stated model or format. These ranges are planning assumptions, not current retailer offers or verified manufacturer prices. Older-device estimates may include remaining stock or refurbished units where explicitly stated. They exclude tax, shipping and optional subscriptions unless the package description says otherwise. A price checked at an official source takes precedence.

Reference prices

Prices are in US dollars and refer to the stated model, bottle size or book edition. Each price includes an official source and the date it was checked. MSRP is used only for a manufacturer-stated suggested retail price. These are reference prices; they are not live Amazon offers. Taxes, shipping, subscriptions and prices for other versions may differ.

Commercial relationships

Affiliate links may earn HTL a commission. Amazon customer ratings are separate from HTL evaluations and are never converted into our scores. No purchase is required to use the library.